Skip to content


Human tissue of deceased used without consent by UK Nuclear Organisations

Summary

An investigation into the legitimacy of testing on human tissue by UK Nuclear Organisations over a period of nearly 40 years has been released.

'The Redfern Inquiry’ (HC 571) concludes that, in many cases, the families had been wronged. Organs were removed at post mortem and provided for analysis despite being of no possible relevance to the cause of death.

The results of radiochemical analysis were seldom taken into account when the death was certified: they were important not for the coronial investigation but primarily for research.

Between 1955 and 1992 organs were removed at post mortem examinations of nuclear workers and subjected to radiochemical analysis at various nuclear laboratory facilities.

The purpose of this independent inquiry was to ascertain whether or not the investigative research conducted by the UK Nuclear Organisations was carried out in accordance with correct and proper procedures and whether the data obtained was used appropriately and with consent.

The Inquiry directed particular attention towards coronial and pathology practice, the number of deceased persons involved, the extent of organ removal and what was done with those organs that had been removed, the uses to which the resulting data were put, issues of knowledge and consent and the role of management.

The blame lies mainly at the door of the pathologists who performed the post mortems. They were ignorant of the law and had not satisfied themselves that the relatives' consent had been obtained. In coronial cases, proper supervision would have prevented the abuse.

Individual chapters examine:

  • British Nuclear Fuels Ltd: the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority;
  • the trade unions and the compensation scheme;
  • the National Radiological Protection Board;
  • the Atomic Weapons Establishment;
  • registries;
  • strontium and the Medical Research Council;
  • West Cumberland Hospital; and
  • the families.

Found this story interesting?
Spread the news by clicking below to add it to your bookmarking service:

Law-Making Explained

This is a Two-Volume Report from the House of Commons (HC 571-I and HC 571-II, 2010-11).

Find out more about House of Commons papers.

How does it affect me?

If you knew any of the deceased used for testing, this affects you.

Further Reading

Keep up-to-date on The Redfern Inquiry.

Read more about the West Cumberland hospital.


Find out how to have your say