Skip to content


Failure of national fire project worst in years, say MPs

Summary

The Committee of Public Accounts has found the project to communicate fire and rescue emergencies to workers at a national level to be the worst failure in years with £469 million of investment wasted.

The FiReControl project was launched in 2004, but following a series of delays and difficulties, was terminated in December 2010 with none of the original objectives achieved, the report 'The Failure of the FiReControl Project’ (HC 1397) details.

FiReControl was an ambitious project with the objectives of improving national resilience, efficiency and technology by replacing the control room functions of 46 local Fire and Rescue Services in England with a network of nine purpose-built regional control centres using a national computer system.

The Department for Communities and Local Government attempted, without sufficient mandatory powers, to impose a single, national approach on locally accountable Fire and Rescue Services who were reluctant to change the way they operated.

There were no basic project approval checks and balances - decisions were taken before a business case, project plan or procurement strategy had been developed and tested.

There were hugely unrealistic forecast costs and savings, naïve over-optimism on the deliverability of the IT solution and under-appreciation or mitigation of the risks.

Fundamentals of project management were absent: the centres were constructed and completed whilst there was considerable delay in even awarding the IT contract, let alone developing the essential IT infrastructure. There was a high turnover of senior managers although none have been held accountable for the failure.

The IT contract went to a company with no direct experience of supplying the emergency services.

£84.8 million has been allocated to meet the project's original objectives, to improve resilience, efficiency and interoperability within the Fire and Rescue Service but there is no certainty this will provide value for money.

Found this story interesting?
Spread the news by clicking below to add it to your bookmarking service:

Law-Making Explained

This is a House of Commons paper (HC 1397, 2010-12). It is a report from the Committee of Public Accounts.

Find out more about House of Commons papers.


Find out how to have your say