Skip to content


Health services must not be compromised despite plans to save billions

Summary

Productivity levels in the National Health Service (NHS) must be significantly improved despite £20 billion year-on-year savings until 2014-15.

'Management of NHS Hospital Productivity’ (HC 741) finds that Government spending on the NHS has increased by 70%, from £60 billion in 2000-01 to £102 billion in 2010-11 with around 40% spent on services provided by acute and foundation hospitals but level of service has not reflected this.

Productivity is defined as the ratio of the volume of resources (inputs) to the quantity of healthcare provided (outputs), adjusted to reflect their relative costs and quality.

There have been significant improvements in the performance of the NHS, particularly in those areas targeted by the Department of Health (DH) such as hospital waiting times and outcomes for patients with cancer and coronary heart disease, but productivity has actually fallen over the last decade.

The Office for National Statistics estimates that, since 2000, total NHS productivity fell by an average of 0.2% a year, and by an average of 1.4% a year in hospitals. The trend of falling productivity will need to be reversed if the NHS is to meet the Department's productivity challenge, to deliver up to £20 billion of efficiency savings a year, by 2014-15, without compromising services.

The Payment by Results approach (a tariff for procedures) has driven some improvements, but it only covers 60% of hospital activity and there is substantial variation in hospital costs and activity. The tariff system could, though, prioritise price over quality.

National pay contracts have not yet been used to manage staff performance effectively, and consultants' productivity has fallen at the same time as they have had significant pay rises.

There are risks to the NHS being able to deliver up to £20 billion savings annually, for reinvestment in healthcare, alongside implementing a substantial agenda of reform. Productivity improvements will be key to delivering these savings.

Found this story interesting?
Spread the news by clicking below to add it to your bookmarking service:

Law-Making Explained

This is a House of Commons paper (HC 741, 2010-11). It is a Report from the Treasury Committee.

Find out more about House of Commons papers.

How does it affect me?

If you would like tax policy to be simple and straightforward, this affects you.

Further Reading

Find out more about the Committee of Public Accounts' work.

Read news about the NHS.


Find out how to have your say