Skip to content


Economic impact of immigration examined

Summary

Immigration has become highly significant to the UK economy as immigrants now comprise 12% of the total workforce. In this Report, 'The Economic Impact of Immigration' (HL 82-I), the House of Lords Select Committee on Economic Affairs examines the impact of immigration on the UK economy.

The Report's conclusions include:

  • The Committee found no evidence for the argument, made by the Government, business and others, that net immigration generates significant economic benefits for the existing UK population.
  • It criticises the use of GDP (gross domestic product) as a criterion for assessing the economic impacts of immigration on the UK. The focus of analysis should be on the effects of immigration on income per head of the resident population and theory and the available empirical evidence indicate that these effects are small.
  • The economic impacts of immigration depend critically on the skills of immigrants.
  • The Committee does not support the general claims that net immigration is indispensable to fill labour and skills shortages and also questions the Government's claim that immigration has generated fiscal benefits.
  • Rising population density has potentially important economic consequences for the resident population, including impacts on housing, as well as wider welfare effects, especially where immigrants are most concentrated. Immigration does exert a significant impact on the housing market in particular areas.
  • Data on immigration and immigrants in the UK, and those leaving the country, are inadequate.

The Committee recommends that the Government should:

  • Radically improve the immigration statistics.
  • Review immigration polices and explain the reasons and objectives.
  • Better enforce the minimum wage.
  • Clarify the objectives and implications of the new points-based immigration system.
  • Monitor immigration by publishing regular reports on the numbers and characteristics of immigrants.
  • Further consider which channels of immigration should lead to settlement and citizenship.
  • Review the implications of its projection of net immigration of 190,000 a year.

Found this story interesting?
Spread the news by clicking below to add it to your bookmarking service:

Law-Making Explained

This is a House of Lords Paper (HL 82-I, 2007-08). It is a Report from the House of Lords Select Committee on Economic Affairs.

Find out more about House of Lords Papers.

How does it affect me?

If you are interested in the economic impact of immigration on the UK population, this affects you.

Prime Minister Gordon Brown has rejected the Committee's calls for a cap on immigration. Shadow Home Secretary, David Davis, said that the Report had 'demolished the Government's case on several fronts'.

Further Reading

Find out more about the House of Lords Select Committee on Economic Affairs

Read the press release regarding this Select Committee Report (1 April 2008)


Find out how to have your say