Skip to content


EU Constitution Reform Treaty examined

Summary

In ‘European Union Intergovernmental Conference’ (HC 1014), the European Scrutiny Committee sets out their conclusions on the EU Constitution Reform Treaty.

The European Union Intergovernmental Conference (IGC) opened on 23 July 2007 and was initiated following a report originally produced by the German Presidency entitled 'Treaty Establishing a Constitution for Europe: Including the Protocols and Annexes, and Final Act with Declarations, Rome, 29 October 2004' (Cm. 6429).

This led to a Draft IGC Mandate setting out a detailed prescription on issues raised by the above report, circulated by the Presidency of the European Council. The Report itself recommended a 'Reform Treaty' that would amend existing treaties and so required an intergovernmental conference.

In this Report, ‘European Union Intergovernmental Conference’ (HC 1014), the European Scrutiny Committee has set out a number of conclusions.

These include:

  • The Committee questioned the aims of the European Council in engaging with EU citizens on the EU Constitution whilst setting out changes to the constitution in an essentially secretive manner.
  • The substance of the Reform Treaty is substantially equivalent to the Constitutional Treaty itself.
  • The Committee is concerned about the UK's position under the Charter.
  • The UK opt-outs that were previously arranged under the Constitutional Treaty will still be retained under the Reform Treaty.
  • The proposals in the Reform Treaty raise a serious difficulty of a constitutional order, appearing to impose a legal duty on national parliaments to the European Union itself. The Committee calls such a legal duty on Parliament objectionable and states that as a matter of principle it should be resisted.

Found this story interesting?
Spread the news by clicking below to add it to your bookmarking service:

Law-Making Explained

This is a House of Commons Paper (HC 1014 2006-07): it is a Report from the European Scrutiny Committee.

Find out more about Select Committee Papers.

How does it affect me?

If you are interested in the European Union Constitution, this affects you.

Have Your Say Now

* Links open in a new window.

Find out more about the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee

Read more on the European Union Reform Treaty


Find out how to have your say