Skip to content


Custodial sentences for knife-carriers 'ineffective'

Summary

Between 2005/06 and 2006/07, the number of knife homicides increased by over a quarter. There also appeared to be a rise in other serious knife violence during this year. A 48% increase in stab-related hospital admissions between 1997/98 and 2006/07 may indicate that knives are being used to inflict more serious wounds.

The majority of knife victims and perpetrators are young men in their late teens and early twenties. The high levels of knife violence since 2006 appear to be the result of an increase in street violence between groups of young people who are sometimes referred to as 'gangs'.

Knife violence is concentrated in the deprived parts of big cities. Most young people who carry knives say they do so for 'protection', but status and peer pressure are also factors.

In this Report, 'Knife Crime' (HC 112-I), the Home Affairs Committee sets out a number of conclusions and recommendations:

  • The Committee is convinced of the need to target knife-carriers and violent offenders separately. For the former, it advocates education in schools about the realities of knife-carrying and measures to help young people feel safer, such as improving confidence in the police and better victim support.
  • The Committee supports the use of stop and search, providing it is carried out in an appropriate manner.
  • The use of custody as an appropriate sentence for the majority of knife-carriers and for violent offenders is offset by high re-offending rates that highlight its ineffectiveness as a long-term solution to violent crime.
  • The Report advocates the adoption of a long-term violence reduction strategy that focuses on prevention.
  • Specific recommendations include early intervention with babies and toddlers born into dysfunctional families, and a more strategic approach to providing diversionary activities and support for excluded young people.

Found this story interesting?
Spread the news by clicking below to add it to your bookmarking service:

Law-Making Explained

This is a House of Commons Paper (HC 112-I, 2008-09). It is a Report from the House of Commons Home Affairs Committee

Find out more about House of Commons Papers.

How does it affect me?

If you have been affected by knife crime, or are interested in the Committee's recommendations for tackling the problem, this may be of interest to you.

Further Reading

Find out more about the Home Affairs Committee

Find out about the Home Office anti-knife crime campaign 'It Doesn't Have to Happen'


Find out how to have your say